Best Smoker Reviews: Electric, Pellet, Charcoal & Gas
Current models, real prices and plain-English buying guides, so you can pick the right smoker for your backyard, your budget and the food you actually cook.
Choose your smoker type
Every type makes good barbecue. They differ in how much flavor you get, how much attention they need, and what you can spend. Start with the one that fits how you cook.
Electric
Plug in, set the temperature, walk away. Easiest to learn and cheapest to run.
From about $200 →Pellet
Real wood fire with a thermostat and app. Smokes, roasts and grills.
From about $420 →Charcoal
Deepest smoke flavor and best bark. Needs a little vent tending.
From about $220 →Gas & Propane
No outlet needed, strong heat in winter, more smoke than electric.
From about $250 →Offset
The classic stick burner. Most rewarding, most hands-on, most flavor.
From about $400 →Our top picks right now
The single best choice in each category, pulled from our full guides. Prices are what we saw on November 19, 2026; they move, so check before you buy.
Masterbuilt 30″ Digital Electric Smoker
710 sq in, 4 racks, side chip loader
The default first smoker for most people: enough space for a family and parts you can still buy in five years.
Traeger Woodridge Pro
970 sq in, 24 lb hopper, Wi-Fi app
Rock-steady temperature, Super Smoke mode for more flavor, and a 10-year warranty.
Weber Smokey Mountain 18″
481 sq in, 2 grates, water pan
Holds 225°F for eight hours on one load of charcoal. The standard for thirty years for a reason.
Masterbuilt MPS 230S 30″ Propane
About 700 sq in, 4 racks, 15,400 BTU
Strong burner for cold days, push-button ignition, and the best-supported propane cabinet you can buy.
Z Grills 450A2
About 450 sq in, 15 lb hopper
Real pellet-grill flavor for under $450, with nearly 4,000 owner ratings behind it.
Oklahoma Joe’s Longhorn Reverse Flow
Reverse-flow cooking chamber, side firebox
Our favorite backyard stick burner: even heat across the grate and enough room for a crowd.
Not sure which type? Compare them
The honest trade-offs in one place. Fuel cost is for a 10-hour brisket cook at typical US prices.
| Type | Smoke flavor | Effort | Fuel cost per 10 hours | Good starting price | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Electric | Light | Lowest | Under $3 | $200 to $300 | Beginners, apartments, cold smoking fish and cheese |
| Pellet | Medium | Low | $10 to $15 | $420 to $1,000 | Set-and-forget cooks, one appliance that also grills |
| Gas & propane | Medium | Low to medium | About $5 | $250 to $400 | No outdoor outlet, winter smoking |
| Charcoal | Strong | Medium | $10 to $15 | $220 to $460 | Bark and smoke ring, best flavor per dollar |
| Offset | Strongest | Highest | $15 to $25 in wood | $400 and up | Pitmasters who enjoy tending a fire |
New to smoking? Start here
Six guides that take you from a new smoker in a box to a brisket worth sharing.
Season your new smoker
The burn-in every smoker needs before the first cook.
2Smoking meat for beginners
Temperatures, timing and the basics that matter.
3Pick the right wood
Hickory, apple, cherry, oak: which wood for which meat.
4Get a good thermometer
The single most useful upgrade for any smoker.
5Smoke your first brisket
The cook everyone wants to master, step by step.
6Keep it clean
Ash, grease and grates: the routine that keeps it running.
Smoker buying FAQ
An electric smoker such as the Masterbuilt 30-inch Digital is the easiest place to start: you set a temperature and it holds it. If you want more smoke flavor and do not mind adjusting vents, the Weber Smokey Mountain 18-inch is the classic beginner charcoal smoker.
Offset and charcoal smokers give the strongest smoke flavor, the thickest bark and the most visible smoke ring. Pellet and gas smokers are in the middle. Electric smokers give the lightest smoke, in exchange for being the easiest to run.
Between $200 and $450 buys a smoker that will last years: a Masterbuilt electric or propane cabinet, a Weber Smokey Mountain, or a Z Grills 450A2 pellet grill. Spend more for capacity, Wi-Fi control or heavier steel, not for better barbecue.
Electric if you want the lowest price and the lowest running cost, under $3 per long cook. Pellet if you want real wood-fire flavor, a smoke ring and an appliance that also grills, for about $10 to $15 in pellets per long cook.
How we choose what to recommend
BestSmokerz has covered backyard smokers since 2016. We only recommend models that are in production right now, and we update each guide when the lineup changes.
- Specs checked against the manufacturer’s own product page.
- Owner reviews read across Amazon, Lowe’s, Home Depot and Walmart for the problems that repeat.
- Long-term ownership threads on Smoking Meat Forums and r/smoking.
- Honest caveats when a popular model has known weak spots.
We are reader-supported. When you buy through our links we may earn an Amazon affiliate commission, at no extra cost to you. It never changes what we recommend.
Browse everything
All our smoker and grill reviews, the accessories hub, BBQ recipes and how-to guides.
Questions about a smoker? Get in touch.
Latest from the blog
- How BBQ and Grill Lovers Can Build
Healthier Eating Habits - 5 Best BBQ Ribs Recipes for Beginners (Pick by the Grill You Own)
- Best Stainless Steel Grill Grates for 2026
- Best Wood Pellets for Smoking
- The Best Offset Smokers for 2026: Real Backyard Stick Burners Reviewed
- 7 Best Weber Grills – Review & Buying Guide 2026




